Ep. 224: Stop Believing Donors Are Tapped Out (with Bloomerang’s CEO)
EPISODE 224
Stop Believing Donors Are Tapped Out (with Bloomerang’s CEO)
About the Episode:
I was sitting in the audience at GiveCon, waiting for my own session, when Bloomerang CEO Dennis Fois put up a slide, and I thought, wait… that’s my slide. We’d never met or compared notes, but we’d both come to the same conclusion: donors haven’t stopped being generous. Nonprofits have stopped talking to them in a way that keeps them close.
Dennis brings something I don’t hear often enough in our sector: the view of someone who has spent 25 years running companies and now spends his days looking at how thousands of nonprofits actually raise money. He’s an optimist with the numbers to back it up, and he’s not shy about challenging the headlines we’ve all started to believe. This conversation is part pep talk, part reality check. Dennis shares how giving actually works for him, which has nothing to do with budgets, and what that means for how you treat a brand-new donor. We also talk about why “playing it safe” can quietly cost your organization more than taking a bold step. If you’ve been carrying the weight of “it’s harder than ever to raise money” this year, listen to this one before your next appeal goes out.
Topics:
Why more than $600 billion in annual giving means there’s no generosity crisis
The wealth transfer that’s already happening, and the new money behind it
Why fewer than 20% of first-time donors give again, and what moves it toward 60%
The honeymoon period most nonprofits skip, and the thank-you stat Dennis calls “terrifying”
Why being single-threaded on one grant or one major donor is risky
Be good and do good: scarcity thinking, overhead and complacency
Why the executive director manages the board, not the other way around
It’s not your stories—it’s how you’re telling them. If your amazing work isn’t getting the attention (and donations) it deserves, it’s time for a messaging shift. The Brave Fundraiser’s Guide guide gives you 10 done-for-you donor prompts to make your message impossible to ignore. Get it for free here! https://christinaedwards.krtra.com/t/xKuLs6tOiPZa
Christina’s Favorite Takeaways:
“There isn't a generosity crisis. There's a communication crisis. Donors are willing to give.” Christina
“There aren't enough hours in the day, and this is when tech can help you.” Christina
“There are so many donors in the world, and donors I have not met yet who want to give. Generosity is not the problem.” Christina
“The most terrifying stat I have for you is that more than half of our customers don't send thank-you emails or happy birthday.” Dennis
“Most non-profits are absolutely unbelievable at sharing their story and passion for their cause.” Dennis
“There is no better time than Q1 to get some systems in place.” Christina
“That moment of giving is actually not that long-lived.” Dennis
“Major donor retention strategy is a really hard act.” Dennis
“At any given point, you don't want a small number of really large clients to have the majority of the revenue of your business.” Dennis
“If you have half a million a year of donations, but it's largely from one individual donor, that is incredibly risky.” Christina
“Is it possible to be good and do good?” Dennis
“Being good requires that you set your own individual standards of excellence, and don't let the environment set those for you.” Dennis
“Your executive director should be leading, and not the other way around.” Christina
“Lead with your head and your heart: be the same person everywhere, and remember that great people can do things that aren’t great and still be great.”
ABOUT Dennis:
Dennis Fois is CEO of Bloomerang, an intelligent giving platform that brings fundraising, donor management, and volunteer management into one unified system. Under his leadership, the company was recapitalized to build a unified giving platform for the nonprofit sector. He brings more than 25 years of software leadership experience across Europe and the U.S., including CEO roles at NewVoiceMedia, Copper CRM, and Rant & Rave. Drawing on that experience, he believes the nonprofit sector is ready to make growth the expectation—and that the technology to support it has finally arrived.
Connect with DenniS:
Episode Resources:
GiveCon 2026: A Celebration of Purpose, People, and What's Possible
Giving USA 2026: Bequests Do the Heavy Lifting as Total Giving Tops $600B
Cerulli Anticipates $124 Trillion in Wealth Will Transfer Through 2048
Bloomerang: A Guide to Donor Retention: Why It Matters for Nonprofits
FREE Resources from Splendid Consulting:
How to Work with Christina and Splendid Consulting:
Connect with Christina and Splendid Consulting:
-
*Links may be affiliate links which means I may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Christina Edwards 0:02Welcome to the Purpose and Profit Club podcast for nonprofit leaders, mission-driven creatives, and social entrepreneurs. Get ready to stop dreaming and start doing. Here, ideas become action. We prioritize purpose and profit. You ready? Let's go. We have a very special guest today, but before I introduce him, I actually am going to tell you how this episode happened, and he may not know this as well. So I was sitting at Gifcon in the audience, listening to Dennis's keynote. I had my own session coming up, and he puts up a slide and starts talking about this very specific thing, and I'm thinking, this is my slide, and that has never happened to me before. We haven't compared notes. We came at this conclusion from different places and landed in the same spot. The way we think about donors, the way we think about generosity trends, and especially this idea, there isn't a generosity crisis. There's a communication crisis. Donors are willing to give, very much so, still willing to give. The question is whether nonprofits are communicating in a way that gets people to care, act, and stay engaged. So I'm very excited to welcome Dennis Foit to the podcast. He is the CEO of Bloomerang, the donor engagement and management platform that 1000s of nonprofits are using to raise money and keep their donors coming back. Welcome to the Purpose and Profit Club podcast, Dennis.
Dannis Fois 1:27
Thank you. I didn't know that at all. What a great story.
Christina Edwards 1:32
So let's talk about what nonprofits are misunderstanding about donor behavior right now, and if generosity isn't the problem? Where is the disconnect?
Dannis Fois 1:42
I have the utmost respect for our customers and the nonprofit sector as a whole. Executive directors, fundraising, they have a very hard and intense job. I think what's not helpful at times is we have the there's a lot of academia around our sector. So there we
Christina Edwards 2:00
have
Dannis Fois 2:00
papers and there is philanthropic research about why people give. There are these big numbers that we all wait for after the giving season. Oh, what happened with the overall fundraising volume, and we all sort of swarm around it. I've started to pay close attention of how those numbers are constructed, and I think what's not that helpful, it it it reminds me a little bit of I spent some of my life in the financial sector, and economists have a similar role in that sector. So where they talk about trends and what's happening in the economy, and these things are directional statements. They're not exact science, and the way they're constructed and connected. And so that's sort of point number one. It's good to have directional statements on what is happening, what the puts and shifts are. I think the overall point, though, though, is when we're taking the number from last year, 612 billion, or whatever that number was, and the year before, 595 billion. The average nonprofit in the U.S. is way below a million dollars of total revenue, I would call it, which includes grants that are. If you took online giving, it's probably a couple of $100,000, maybe even less. So, if you're thinking about the typical nonprofit, let's make it simple for us. Let's call it a million dollars. Very generous because that's really not the average or median. It just doesn't make sense to say that that market of $616 billion, the market of the money flowing, is not large enough to do really, really well in that sector. To give you an idea, if I would say that to our board, I would be fired as a Bloomerite CEO. If I if I had to apply the same sentiment to the company, our market. If I look at what is the total addressable market for Bloomerang, is much smaller than what we are talking about. So when I when we when I say hey there is no generosity crisis, what I'm really meaning about number one we are in a growing market. Number two the structural tailwinds that are going to help us. That is actually putting more dollars into the system. We can talk about that. Yeah. So wow, the whole market is growing. And number three, all of us, all of our nonprofits, are so small in that pie that we can literally decide to add a non. We can double or triple our size if we want to, and we still will not run out of market. So that's what it comes from. Now, unfortunately, there's a lot of academia and you're really light and trans, and it kind of like makes you feel like there is like a ceiling on what you can accomplish, and that is deeply unhelpful. And so I'm gonna do my very best to dismantle those arguments because they're they're not grounded in science. They're presented often as facts and science. They're not particularly scientific. So that's sort of point number one on what is no generosity crisis.
Christina Edwards 4:47
Talk to me about the structural tailwinds.
Dannis Fois 4:49
Yeah. So a couple of things. I think this might connect to why you very strongly fear out the communication problem. Is for the longest of time we've been talking about the wealth. Transfer. When is it coming? And I started studying this like a few years ago. And so the question I asked is, well, isn't it already happening? What am I missing? If the wealth transfer is basically the younger generation, so we have Gen Xers now, exceptions becoming the recipients of funds, and and then we have the millennials. After that, if we can sort of categorize it like that. And the question was basically, oh, the the theory was always, oh well, it's coming to happen, so be ready. And so the question I asked is, well, why is it not already happening? It makes no sense because if you look at the age of people and our average lifespan, it should already be happening. And turns out that that's probably true. It is. We're in it. We're in that way. You can see it, by the way, when you follow those same large studies that estates, the guests, etc., etc. It's all growing very, very fast. DAFs to donor advised funds. So we see that it is happening. So number one, we have that generational wealth transferring, and we're in the middle of it. And you know, you can follow the number. Some people say 120 trillion of wealth, of which 18 trillion. So 18. If you take that number, that 18 trillion number that's been banded around to be appointed for generosity, that is many, many, many, many, many, many, many times the size of what we just talked about was a record year last year at 620 billion. So, like we're basically saying, wow, there is just more coming, and then there is the additional immediate factor of these large technology revolutions,
Christina Edwards 6:30
AI millionaires or billionaires, whatever we call them, that also want to deploy more capital into the sector. So, it's nothing is intimated that there is going to be a shortage of funds flowing in the sector. In fact, quite to the contrary, we should be very optimistic about that. So that's why I'm saying tailwinds. Like this is, if you were a commercial enterprise, you'd be salivating at these trends. You'd be thinking, "Are you kidding me? I'm the luckiest person in the world." Why aren't we then? Why? Why aren't we? Is it just repeating what has been presented over and over and over again to where you said, you know, you just start to believe it, and you start to believe it, opinion pieces as fact. You start to believe small data pools as as fact. Like, why aren't we excited?
Dannis Fois 7:20
Some folks are when we hear the prospects conversation. I like the prospect conversation because I sort of tell you about folks making changes, right? They they are talking about. I want to raise my fundraising goal. I want to set a goal. I want to be audacious with myself. That is definitely changing. First of what I've seen last year. So that's I think awesome trend. Like now, there's a talk about setting unrealistic targets. I don't think they should come from the board. I think they should be targets that the team is setting. But if the team is excited about it, I'm all for it. Shoot for something that you think you can achieve and try to get past it. Amazing. The other factor is it is very hard out in the field when yeah you're doing one event after another, and and I think the structural problem is it's a leaky bucket, right? So when you you feel like you're treading water, where if you know what we call a healthy nonprofit has a donor retention of in the mid 50%, well, you can run a business on those numbers. It would be impossible. So it's it's a it's an unbelievable drag. You don't start at zero year a year. You start at minus 45 or minus 50, whatever your the opposite of your retention rate is. So you know that that is very very hard. Now, this is I think part of the issue is we focus so much on retaining the donors that give recur like on a periodic basis. So the aging donors, we focus really hard. The last 10 years have really been about on donor retention. I mean, at Bloomer, we built our business around it. And with this shift, it's extremely important that the early life of the donor with your organization is really well nurtured. It's very clear now that most donors. I mean, in fact, fewer than 20% of first-time donors give again. Yep. Yep. So, like that, you got to change that. You have to also know that if you communicate with them and if you do things like you know from from the basis of thanks, you know, it's through to somebody dropping a call. So that number shifts enormously to moving from 20% to 60%, but that is not happening, and I think that's not happening because we're also trying to hold on on on these aging donors. So we try to juggle those balls, and I wonder at times whether we're making the right priorities. That's sort of the the question that I don't want to dismiss it as it's psychologically hard to be in a nonprofit and try to spin all the place, and the kind of thing is also most of the executive directors or the fundraising directors I speak to are so passionate about their course; they really want to spend time with the course, and this sort of feels more like sales tactics and playbooks and admin, and it sort of feels like. How how much of it do we need to do alongside of the mission?
Christina Edwards 10:03
And when you couple that with the headline that you know it's tougher than ever to raise, it's donors are you know feeling the pinch. Then of course the director of development is going to talk themselves out of making that call, following up on the follow up, booking that meeting because they're thinking, oh, I don't want to do this. Oh, I don't want to do this. And I call that new donor period the honeymoon period because it's such an essential part for a new donor. But yeah, when you're when you only have so many hours in the day and you're focusing on the other donor segment, it does feel like we don't have enough time for everything. There aren't enough hours in the day. I don't know what to prioritize, and this is when tech can help you. For anyone listening, this is when tech can help you. We can put some automations in place, but this does have to, I think, foundationally, and that's why I wanted to have this conversation. You foundationally have to come at it from there are so many donors in the world, and donors I have not met yet who want to give generosity is not the problem.
Dannis Fois 11:05
Oh, and I think you. I think this is probably the most important subject. This idea of that honeymoon period, what you talk about. If I my the most terrifying stat I have for you is that more than half of our customers don't send thank you emails or happy birthday or like to your point of can't you just at least automate that and make it you could and not only automate it nowadays you could also personalize and automate it so that's right you don't have to have a standard email anymore it's or or it could be a text message it could be whatever it's not for the not willing wanting to do it it's it's I think it's just a head full of other things, and not prior, not setting these things in motion so that they help you. But I think it's funny because I talk to a lot of philanthropists, and then it's sort of the question I always ask: Do you plan? I'm sort of interested. These people have my theory is that there is no budget for most people. There is no real budget, so that's my theory. So this idea of people feeling the pinch, I don't believe because most, if not all, of my giving has never been with. I got to do this and that and that this here, and I'm planning to spend this. What happens is this: I go to somewhere, usually an event, a person that starts talking about it. I do a lot of like charity rally. I love old cars, so I get involved in that world, and there's often like charity, reality, and whatever. And then there would be someone that speaks on behalf of their nonprofit organization, because that's most of the process, if not all of the proceeds, go to multiple causes. What happens is, like that person touches my heart in some way, and I give something, and that's so. It's it's just a the most human act that I can think of, and so no planning. I wasn't planning to spend. I don't not even moment thinking about whether what. It's just like that person touched my heart, and I want to do something. I think then that is so precious that you have to treat it as such. It's almost like you've created a new customer, which you have. It is to me a tragedy then that you basically then almost go on to the next next event or the next thing to do. So what I'm seeing is most of non-profits are absolutely unbelievable at sharing their story or their passion for their cause, and I mean unbelievable. I have to. I mean, we talked about that gift. Come, I really, truly feel that in the U.S. we got a couple of things wrong. We celebrate the entrepreneurs a lot because they come like, especially we love the self-made person. For me, like, there's another level here, which is basically imagine that you get out of bed every morning to right some wrong or to fight for a cause that nobody else is fighting for, but not for personal enrichment, but to actually make that right. For me, that sits at another level of aspiration. I talk about heroes, and what is fascinating to me is, boy oh boy, are folks good at sharing their story and getting us to fall in love with what they're doing, and and and at times like, wow, you're doing all of this; it's unbelievable. It's sort of the machinery, the apparatus alongside it that is weak. What you call the communication crisis, which is, and I understand there's sort of no time, but the problem is if you don't make time for it, you're just going to be trapped in that wheel of you're going to be the limiting factor, which is you can only do so many events, and the round, around, around we go, and I think it just gets progressively harder. It starts to weigh, which eventually then impacts your ability to convey the story enthusiastically, which is painful.
Christina Edwards 14:35
And listen, y'all, q1 is coming up.
Dannis Fois 14:39
Yeah,
Christina Edwards 14:39
I find for most organizations there is no better time than Q1 to get some systems in place. You're not actively fundraising as you were in year end, and Q1 is a great time to set up any automations. When we were talking about automating even a thank you, what I could hear so many of my clients, executive. Directors, development directors say is, I should really send them a thank you card. I don't want to send them a thank you email. And it's this, and even that you like talk yourself out of doing it. Or I don't have time to set up the automation. And it's like, what is baseline? Baseline is that 30 day retention window. Let's get something baseline there. Then, as you get your systems in place, then you can send a thank you card. Like we can always do more, but if we foundationally have something running in the background, you're going to see an increase in retention, and then you're going to see an increase in the feeling of like not treading water all the time, not filling a leaky bucket. That's what it feels like. I think for so many organizations, and I think in the past year, two years, it's felt that they are working harder to tread the same water. So it's I'm treading in place, but I'm putting out more time calories to tread there. And I think a lot of that has been in response to grant funds being paused, pulled out, and needing to move towards individuals, which is really, really key, and I think it's important to separate generosity and a crisis of generosity with is this thing over here with our grants that we used to rely on affecting how I feel about the whole landscape.
Dannis Fois 16:15
Yeah, I think you're touching on a couple of really important facts that are just real, and they absolutely weigh on day to day. A couple of things on the. I love receiving a card or a thing or something simple, and or an email or text message or a voice message or whatever. I think people should not forget that that moment of giving is actually not that long lived. Like so, I would do something. I if I just speak for myself, I would give something. Maybe talk about it for a few times. I met this person. Oh my goodness, she's doing all of these things. Wow! And eventually, it sort of goes out of my mind. My work takes over. My auto, my worries take over. My health, whatever's going on in my life, and it's taking a different place in my head and heart to remind me of that thing, shouldn't we even be up for discussion? It should be mandatory. It should be saying no. I don't care that you don't like it. You should just do it and use your board. Like I find it, you know, if you're a nonprofit board, getting an email or a note or something from a board like that, we can use people around us to do the trustees, what have you. Let's put them to work. You know, it's not really work to send somebody a thank you note, is it? That's what a wonderful thing to do. The point on the shift from public to private funding is real, and I think it comes down all to the same thing. And that's basically we need to. It's not just about the dollars that we are raising. I think we need to think about building sustainable revenue streams for nonprofits and really think about what does good look like for us. So, how much recurring, like, is it is a pot of smaller, highly recurring donations actually a good thing for us versus transactionally? I would argue yes, it is. I don't know for your organization specifically. We could do some work on it. What that could be, but that's thought, especially if you believe there's a part of society and population that is squeezed. Well, most folks can do 1020, 2530 bucks a month. That's right. It doesn't matter, but it can be done, right? And instead of asking them with a ladder for 150 and 200 bucks, which might be a little steep, asking somebody to say, "Well, maybe make that recurring for $20," isn't easy to again not enough being done, and it's much higher retaining and more sustainable. Now we start next year, but upon the major donors are dying, and when we're looking at their my kids don't really care. I mean, I love like animal rescues; that's really into me into dogs and stuff. And my kids different ideas about that. So when I am gone, I'm pretty certain that they will have different thoughts and philosophies about that. So retain major donor retention strategy is a really hard act. Grants, they're not gone. They're gone from the public sector, and I I am one of those people that believes that we will never go. This is this genius now out of the bottle. We will never go to the level of government funding that we used to have, let's call it, right after COVID, up to that point. But we also see at the same time that it's actually more than offset by private funding. Yep, it is harder to find because it's not centralized. So now this grant discovery is important, etc., etc. So don't dismiss that this is a very real problem. But it all points to the same thing, which is you cannot be single threaded on either major donors, reliant, or a major grant, or we have to build sustainable pots. Like the way I run our business is in in business we call it key client concentration risk, which is the same thing, which basically means that any a small number of really large clients to have the majority of the revenue of your business, and very often 8020 is mentioned. 20% of the donors or customers have 80% of the revenue. I think in this day and age, that is not a good setup. You should actively work strategically with.
Dannis Fois 19:59
The board to develop not just so. This is where just chasing a number. Hey, we want to go for 1 million to 1.1 or 1.2 million, is not the holy grail. It could very well be. Hey, that 1 million is actually perfectly fine, but we don't like the fact that $600,000 comes from this grant or $200,000 comes from this person and they're aging, and we start to get increasingly less. And then what?
Christina Edwards 20:25
Yeah, exactly. I was going over a client intake form earlier this year, and I have a program that's really slated for newer nonprofits for organizations who haven't built their first 100k in unrestricted giving, individual giving, and they were doing 10 million a year, and I was like, "Oh, they joined the wrong program. They need to be in the club." And I looked a little closer, and I was like, "They have two donors. Everything is grant funded. They are in the right program, and they're seeing. They're seeing we've got to diversify." And I've had that again and again and again. Where oh well, we do half a million a year, but it's largely from one individual donor, and that is incredibly risky. So, looking at you don't have to be funded all one way, right? So it's not just you can't ever get a grant again. It's looking at it in a diversified way. The other piece I want to offer our listeners is this idea that it is hard to find because there isn't a central resource for major donors, right? Not like there is a grant search tool or something like that. But listen, you mentioned dogs, cat people. I always tell my clients: cat people hang out with cat people, dog people hang out with dog people, cars. I see cars in your background. Car people hang out with car people. So if you can find one, you have a pipeline to more. So it is a different muscle. It's a different skill to build out, but it can be done.
Dannis Fois 21:51
That's the thing that I think that is it. You you nailed it. At this point, you're not talking about your nonprofit and your cause. At this point, you're talking about the pipeline of funding, future funding, and that I realize that that's a very different set of skills, which is about I think after a certain size of a nonprofit, it is a good idea to have a a fundraiser, a fundraising director of to actually go out and to have a strategy because I I think that sometimes the numbers get misconstrued, right? So there's sort of this board to say, oh, we need to raise our fundraising goals. It's like, well, maybe, but it depends on the health of the current base of funding, and it's it's it's all sort of been simplified in in in some simple numbers, and it might not be the right thing for everyone. To the to the examples that you mentioned before, and I do also agree with your point of view that we can make it as complicated as we want, or can make it really simple.
Christina Edwards 22:44
Let's talk a bit about scarcity thinking. Scarcity thinking is something that is pretty embedded in the nonprofit sector, and one of the ways it predominantly shows up is around overhead, which you've called I love. I love your LinkedIn the overhead myth as slow sabotage. Walk me through your thoughts about what's going on here.
Dannis Fois 23:05
I'm a bit the marketing team finds me dangerous at times because I actually write my own LinkedIn posts. So I do. So often, like, what's what's what are we sending out? It it sort of feels to me like there is this balance between, and I want to say this right between accepting that scarcity is the sort of a natural condition of doing good, so you can call it humility. Does that make sense?
Christina Edwards 23:28
Yeah,
Dannis Fois 23:29
it's a really tricky thing because it's self-reinforcing. You sort of believe you can't invest, and I think it's a really tricky thing to say. At Bloomerang, we have a similar dynamic. So I always say I really feel that the we need to raise the standard and the bar for the sector because the sector has a natural tendency to sort of regress to to sort of a place of survival, if you like. So this comes from all of the data that we talked about. So like we make like struggle and survival, but not thriving ambition as a sector whole. Again, we're speaking in generalizations. I know there's folks that are absolutely super ambitious about what they stand for, but somehow, if you're long enough in the sector, it sort of feels like it's hard and it's harder every year and all of this. And at the same time, you look at the data, I say, well, that makes no sense at all because our market is growing. There's more information. Yeah, everything is complicated, but it's getting bigger too. So this mindset comes for me is is a tricky one. And I always say, well, look at your heroes. Who are your heroes? For me, my heroes always have some sort of characteristics where they absolutely awesome on what they do. Like for me, it's like tennis. I love tennis. So I used to grow up with all these people. But I love athletes that are phenomenal what they do, but they're also amazing human beings. They're very kind. So can you be good and do good? Is it possible to be good and do good? And sort of that's what we talk about a lot at Bloomer because a lot of people sort of want to do good, but the lack of. Off the hook a little bit of being good, if that makes sense. So in other words, say
Christina Edwards 25:04
more about being good,
Dannis Fois 25:05
right? So being good for me is that, and it's very hard in our sector. Being good requires that you set your own individual standards of excellence, and don't let the environment set those for you, right? So you have this is your life. You're choosing. You have decided to do this, and whether that's becoming a nonprofit professional or working at Bloomerang, you have to be your best. You can't let yourself kid yourself and say, "Well, because I do good, I therefore I'm good." That's not true at all, at all. You need to just one simple test. You have to get up every time in the morning when you look in the morning to either shave or put makeup or just look and brush your teeth. You have to look at yourself and really love what you're seeing. Seeing, I am like I'm giving it my best. I'm really driving here. I'm doing this, and that is being good. And this sector needs that more than ever. And there is at times very often this sort of conversation about, I won't quite call it complacency, but that's what it feels like at times. It sort of said, "Well, this is like an immovable object; can't do much about it. It is. It's been like this all the time." And the reality is, well, that's not how it would work if you were in a competitive sector where somebody else was trying to eat your lunch. So you shouldn't accept that because it's not good for you. It doesn't. It's not good for anyone. It doesn't. You need. We need to be good at what we do because that forces growth. That that keeps us curious about new ideas and it keeps us sharp. And so I think it's extremely important when we're thinking about this scarcity mindset is that we separate out doing good and being good and demand both from each other, and not allow that somebody says, "Well, I'm really good about what I do because I do X, Y, Z." Well, that's really not right.
Christina Edwards 26:52
I think the complacency piece can sound and feel reasonable. It also could feel responsible, like, "Oh, we'll just do what we did last year, but it is not responsible. It is irresponsible. It's especially irresponsible to the people you serve, the communities you serve, because we know that it costs more this year than it did last year to put on your program or service. So you need more funding, and so there's that piece. And when you were talking, the other piece that reminded me of I'm in Atlanta. There's a big tree outside my window here, and it's what's happening all day is little squirrels are picking up the acorns to get ready for winter. Right? They're like grabbing them, and that is what a lot of organizations are doing. They are like, okay, it's tough right now. I'm seeing these headlines. I'm hearing it from the water cooler, or from wherever, how hard it is, and this and that and the other. So I'm going to hold tighter to my acorns, to my dollars. I'm not going to make investments, whether it's investments in our team, investments in our tech, investments in support, however it looks, because I had to hold too tightly. And then that overhead myth, right? You hold too tightly, then you don't find out a way through and up towards sustainably growing, and so it ends up just being the self-fulfilling prophecy that I see. I
Dannis Fois 28:11
think that's an unbelievably important situation there that you're sketching. The for me, this also connects to how you manage a board, and I've been running companies for a long time, so dealing with boards and investors and stakeholders, etc., is sort of part of my my job. So think about it this way: if we go back to this point of try to be good, I'm going to raise the bar and raise the standard. You're so much more investable because what happens is every meeting that you're at, you're constantly talking about a path for more, a path for better, a way to do X, a way to go Y. You don't have to do anything for anybody to come up with objections and numbers and things to tell you why the sector. Like, don't have. You know, so I always think about what I spend my energy on. Right? Do I spend my energy on stuff that is automatic, or do I spend my energy on stuff that I can actually influence? There is literally, if you and I stop talking, the sector will continue to talk until we're both blue in the face about how what the numbers are, what's like. So great, that saves me not having to talk about it. So what do I talk about? What I talk about is ideas, tactics, opportunities that I see, but if I look at a board, if I talk to my board and I see them as investors, and even if I look at myself, I'm much more likely to support or or or do something with somebody that gives me a little energy boost when I see them because they see the world in a different way. They see fraternity. They see action, they see mobility, and it we're not. They're not seeing a self-imposed constraint. Like, like let's be honest, when you're looking at your nonprofit in the context of the USA, all the constraints are pretty much self-imposed. So, and I absolute, I am one of those people that doesn't believe at all in this whole myth of having to underfund or be. Like no, I want nonprofits to be super well funded. The only thing is, you just need to promise transparency and show where the dollars are going with it. I want I want nonprofit. I think one of the issues is that a lot of talent can't afford to be employed at an. So there's a structural issue. So if we want to get better, we need to break that. So I can promise you, non-profits that I'm aboard that I want to pay market for someone if they're really, really good. So, but these all of these things are self-imposed. But what doesn't help if the the executive directors or the fundraising directors don't bring ambition to the table, because the reality is to believe that you need more investment. You need to believe in those people running the thing. And so, at that point, at that point, I'm envisaging like it's a bit like Shark Tank, right? You come and pitch, and it does need to feel. So I feel very passionately that an executive director manages the board, and the board does not manage the nonprofit. There it is. There it is. There
Christina Edwards 31:01
it is. Your executive director should be leading, and not the other way around. And the best board meetings I've sat in, that is what's happening. Yeah, that is what's happening. But you're talking about a fire. You're talking about a fire. You're talking about an ambition, and all of that is magnetic for donors. It is magnetic for prospects. We are drawn to that fire because we're we see it, we read it in an email, and we're like, they are doing something big. I want to fund that. We are not drawn to make a difference language that everybody has.
Dannis Fois 31:35
I could I could not agree with you more, and and that might be a little intimidating at times for folks, but I would love. I think the sector would benefit, and most most people think like that rather than that. You know, I've had folks that said to me, "I need to take this proposal to the board." I'm thinking, "Whoa, this is only like a couple of $1,000. You're like a pretty big nonprofit."
Christina Edwards 31:54
That's right.
Dannis Fois 31:54
It's going, and and that's a really clear sign of a poorly constructed governance and operating environment, which tells me immediately that there is some sort of a dynamic underpinning that. When I when I retire, I'm going to help with the conversations on nonprofits or on board management at some point. Many many.
Christina Edwards 32:16
I think it tends to be too, and this could be its own episode. Is a a lot of executive directors ended up in that role not from just through trial and error. Maybe they came through programs. Maybe they came in as a fundraiser. Maybe they're the founder. And there ends up being this mentality too because they haven't done that before. They haven't managed the board before. So it's group thinking. What do you think we should do? What do you think we should do? Should we? Will you review this proposal?
Dannis Fois 32:44
It's expensive and inefficient, and I think it leads to this idea of, you know, the easiest thing to manage in the absence of ambitions and plan is costs. Everybody will have an opinion about your cost. So if you have a P and L, right? The cost part of it is anybody can wrap their head around that. Like this is this, and this is that. So again, this is one of those things you don't have to spend any time on because other than making sure that the numbers add up and it's a fine proposal, you know that whatever, whenever you put costs in front of someone, somebody will have an opinion about it. So really, I would spend zero time on that. What I would spend time on is how do we get better? What great ideas would have? And I would challenge my board because if the board doesn't bring ideas, I have questions about it too, right? So I've sat in a meeting where folks were talking about the salary of someone, and man, that salary was so low. And then at the same time, sort of asked the questions of how many at the board had actually given this year, and only half at the board. And I was thinking, well, this was a pretty wealthy setup. So if everybody gave $5,000 this year, which those people could easily afford, we could squash that salary conversation right there and then. So there's there's sort of this, which by the way, if I was the long senator director, is exactly what I would have done. I said, hey, yeah, we can afford this person. It only requires all of you to give this year. Yeah. So you have to be, you have to be
Christina Edwards 34:01
willing to be having those conversations, those hard conversations. Yeah, which is we need to retain this person. They're going to go leave the sector if we don't pay them well.
Dannis Fois 34:10
It shouldn't just be that you you can go and work at the nonprofit if you don't have to work or can afford not to. That I think that's a really very very small slice of the market. What we want is be able to sort of tap into. So I think starting with good median salaries would be a really great way to start because it allows us to expand that and then hold to the point on bed where you need to be good. That's the other side of it. You need to be good and do good. That in itself is hard to find great people that want to do this. And I think most of us would find it totally acceptable to make it maybe 10, 15%, 15% trade on. Hey, I could possibly earn a little bit more, but I love this so much that for most of us that works. But 40% less than like that makes no sense for anyone, and and especially not with how expensive things are getting. So, but it all for me, it all goes back to. Same principle, which is what is the ambition and the ideas and the proposals of that nonprofit. It's not about the sector, what the sector pay. You could decide today in a nonprofit to pay market rates.
Christina Edwards 35:11
We
Dannis Fois 35:11
don't need the sector approval for that. We just need an ambitious set of individuals to say, "I found this person. This person can come and work here. I then need $20,000 more than we had budgeted for, but they are going to be a change maker in this organization. I want to hire this person. How can we make it happen?
Christina Edwards 35:28
And who would you be if that was the way you led your organization? What would your organization be like five years from now? Like,
Christina Edwards 35:35
and it is a blue ocean opportunity. All of this, whether it's communication, whether it's investing in people, whether it's squashing the overhead myth, because so many nonprofits aren't doing this, that this is such a wide open opportunity for you to do this with your donors, with your email subscribers, with your audience to really stand out would be easier than it would be for for companies who are not nonprofits, right? Because there's so many nonprofits not doing this. The
Dannis Fois 36:05
amount of so the the I cannot agree with you more now more than ever, especially younger people. They want their job to have meaning and impact. It's not just a job.
Christina Edwards 36:15
That's right. That's right.
Dannis Fois 36:16
It's very clear. It's so abundantly clear. In fact, a lot of our candidates that applied to Bloomerang lead with that message. Oh, I love because this allows me to have more impact because it sort of touches more nonprofits. There's still the small manner that you have to be good too, right? But you're so right. Like I see this as a tailwind again. Like there's a whole generation that is super savvy with AI. Is very savvy with social media. They can help to have a greater reach that can be employed or can be put or volunteer, and instead of yeah, they can actually help with the marketing. So there's so so many opportunities to to tap into talent, but it requires a different mind, a growth mindset, a mindset where you look at this and say, like, this is fantastic. We just, this is, we could just keep growing here. How am? How do I make this enduring? That this company keeps, this, this nonprofit keeps on going well beyond my average, and that I think should should be every everybody's goal.
Christina Edwards 37:16
We could talk for another hour. I loved this conversation, but I want to respect your time. We ask every guest to share with us a belief, a mantra, maybe a favorite quote that shapes how you show up in the world. Something you like to come back to, and I'd love to have you share yours with our listeners.
Dannis Fois 37:36
Something that's been with me for a very long time is is is head and heart, so I I feel that to lead you need to be the same person. So I'm not one of those people that believes that it's a different personality when you're in your professional and your life. For me, it was always there's just one version of me, and I've been able to make sense of that by having a mental image of a scale with a head and a heart. And in fact, when I joined Bloomerang many many years ago, I introduced myself at that scale, and there was a brain and a brain emoji and a heart emoji on one side. And I feel it's extremely important for me. It's something around intellectual honesty, so I'm very dispassionate about the numbers and the situation, and then separate out the person from the situation. So in other words, great people can do bad things, bad projects, and then that thing is not great, but that person is still great, and vice versa. And I try to navigate decision making and how I live my life, which is in large part also work through that lens of head and heart. And at the end of the day, or the start of the following, when I shave in the morning, I look myself in the mirror, find, and I ask myself how that scale is looking, and and if I don't like very often it's more head, then I need to put sort of more heart on the scale, and then I go to work that day with a slightly different mindset.
Christina Edwards 38:52
I love that. Thank you so much for your time, and we will link to your LinkedIn and lots about Bloomerang and the Giving signals report because we did pull a lot of our conversation from some of the data I'd read in there. So we'll link to that as well in the show notes. Thank you so much, Dennis.
Dannis Fois 39:09
Thank you.
Christina Edwards 39:10
Hey, high achiever. I know your sights are set on ambitious, world-changing goals. In the Purpose and Profit Club group coaching program, you can get the support, motivation, and strategy to accelerate your impact. I like to say it's where the inner work meets big impact and big funding. Go to splendidcourses.com/waitlist, and you will be first to be notified when we open up doors, and you'll get special bonuses when you join our waitlist. See you inside.